Is Lisa Giampa as bad as C.J. Ross?

[Bo-Bo24]

114 - 114 was a disgrace and quite frankly it pushes womens involvement in sport back by years

[generalbulldog]

This is why women should not be involved in judging boxing matches, figure skating yes, boxing no.

[Silkeyjoe]

There are male judges equally as bad as these women. Theres also a shitload of men on this forum who cannot score a fight for their lives, so it is not a sex thing. I do think judges should have some experience with boxing (eg former boxer/trainer etc themselves before they can even apply to become a judge. Im pretty sure CJ Ross had none.

[J_Undisputed]

Well.. from one decision I can't say yes or no, but Checking boxrec, she has a history of these kind of decisions. Scoring the fights closer than the other 2 judges in most of her fights. With the benefit of her husband's experience, she should definitely not be making these kind of gaffes.

Good Read on Chuck:Judge Emeritus Chuck Giampa: You can't have robots deciding who wins fights - National Boxing | Examiner.com

One thing I will say is it seems more and more common now for that one judge to go the other way, when you have a tough exciting fight. I dont know if: a.)they're paid for their vote and follow through no matter what the result so they can be approached again on another fight. b.)Are trying to keep the young names alive for the future of boxing or c.) trying to keep a shred of doubt there to justify rematch possibilities. Its probably none of the three or it could be all of the 3.

The more common explanation. She bit on the flashy shoe-shining by Russell, which had my thinking my TV was off or something when he exhaled like 6 times and threw 3 punches in those flurries.

[Ron Swanson]

There are male judges equally as bad as these women. Theres also a shitload of men on this forum who cannot score a fight for their lives, so it is not a sex thing. I do think judges should have some experience with boxing (eg former boxer/trainer etc themselves before they can even apply to become a judge. Im pretty sure CJ Ross had none.

Exactly, it has nothing to do with male/female. And moronic suggestions that it does serve no purpose other than to say "look, I'm a caveman who's never picked up a book".

[Dia bando]

She is a bit like Roy Hogson likes a DRAW.

[Freedom]

Lisa Giampa is either incompetent or she was paid off by Al Haymon.

Russell hardly landed any clean effective punches. Lomachenko out-landed him in every round but one.

I scored it 118-110 for Lomachenko.

[Silkeyjoe]

Lisa Giampa is either incompetent or she was paid off by Al Haymon.

Russell hardly landed any clean effective punches. Lomachenko out-landed him in every round but one.

I scored it 118-110 for Lomachenko.

I havent seen the fight yet and just about to watch it now but u were as far off the 2 judges as Giampa was

[holmcall]

Lisa Giampa is either incompetent or she was paid off by Al Haymon.

Russell hardly landed any clean effective punches. Lomachenko out-landed him in every round but one.

I scored it 118-110 for Lomachenko.

I had it 117-111