Quote Originally Posted by VG_Addict View Post
How good would you say it is? I think it's pretty good. Even without fighting everyone, he still has wins over:

Canelo
Hatton
Marquez
Guerrero
Judah
Hernandez
Corrales
Manfredy
Cotto
Castillo
Judah had 2 losses in his last 6 when Floyd fought him, including his last fight, a decision loss to Baldomir

Hatton was extremely overrated; he beat Tszyu, but it would have been different in America, I don't think he would have been able to fight the same way, but that was about it. I mean he beat an old Castillo, but not an impressive win for Floyd

Marquez was very undersized, came up 2 weight classes, and Floyd didn't even make weight. Garbage

Genaro Hernandez was a very impressive win. He doesn't get enough credit for that one.

Corrales was also a very big notch in his belt.

Cotto was a good win, but again, Floyd only fought him after multiple losses and 2 knockouts. He should have fought him before Margarito. can't use the money excuse with that one. Cotto has always been a draw.

Floyd's ultimate knock has been he ducked guys. Didn't fight Cotto or Mosley in their prime, never fought Tszyu, Paul Williams or Margarito. Didn't fight Pacquiao.

I think he could have won all those fights, but we'll never know.