Quote Originally Posted by Beanflicker View Post
Quote Originally Posted by mikeeod View Post
Just curious if you place Floyd on the same level as guys like Duran and Julio Ceasar Chavez (sr., of course!)? Floyd impressed me with his infighting ability vs Hatton, but I feel like he was ineffective vs Maidana and Castillo which is why he reverted to a more mobile style in both rematches. I'm not sure I would consider Floyd one of the greatest in fighters ever due to his performances in those fights, but the guy is definitely capable in my opinion.
If you look at effectiveness on the inside - damage done vs damage received - Mayweather is one of the greatest in-fighters there's ever been. In-fighting is not all about offensive, you have to factor in defence as well, and even now in his older age Floyd is probably the hardest guy to land clean on on the inside in the history of boxing.

I wouldn't put Floyd up with a true inside fighter because inside fighting is only one aspect of Floyd's game whereas real inside guys live and die on the inside, but in terms of stifling offence and landing his own accurate counter shots, Floyd has to be acknowledged as a truly great inside guy.

I'll say this too, and I know I'll get tons of people disagreeing with me: prime Floyd (130-140) gets the better of prime Duran (135) on the inside.
Interesting post.
I do think Mayweather was a better fighter down at those weights than he is now but I wouldn't be wise of him to try to go on the inside against Duran. His best chance would be to box and stay on his bike.