Is Floyd an ATG?

[fan johnny]

Is he an ATG, or has he avoided too many fighters?

I would say in terms of pure ability, he's up there with the very best.

I guarantee you, if he fought and beat Pacquiao back in 2009-2010, people would be calling him a top 10 ATG.

First what is "your" criteria for ATG?

Why would a great boxer beating a great fighter both past thier physical primes make a difference in ranking either one of them, other than what you have already to place them on your list. I guarantee you, that most ATG lists that have been made, have changed over the last 20 years even though nothing in history has changed.

[VG_Addict]

Is he an ATG, or has he avoided too many fighters?

I would say in terms of pure ability, he's up there with the very best.

I guarantee you, if he fought and beat Pacquiao back in 2009-2010, people would be calling him a top 10 ATG.

First what is "your" criteria for ATG?

Why would a great boxer beating a great fighter both past thier physical primes make a difference in ranking either one of them, other than what you have already to place them on your list. I guarantee you, that most ATG lists that have been made, have changed over the last 20 years even though nothing in history has changed.

Past their physical primes? What? Pacquiao was at his best in 2009-2010.