Re: Earnie Shavers vs. Howard Smith ~ 'Championship Qualifier' - Winner Gets Muhammad

Originally Posted by
Master
Why on earth would you not count the last 3 rounds? @
Max Power. Those were championship rounds which separated the true greats from the also ran’s.
Remember this was not the best Ali and he still suckered and out hustled a puncher like Shavers.
If a fighter manages to KO an opponent in round 13+ in a nostalgic fight that's fine but when I'm comparing it to a modern boxer, I think it should be dismissed as an "overly-late KO".
In my opinion if the boxer failed to KO his opponent in 12 rounds, in modern times it would be scored as a decision.
Not being able to KO the opponent in 12 rounds is a sign of failure of plan and skills and any KO in round 13+ is most likely a stamina gas related KO (as visibly most are), nobody plans to KO an opponent in such a late round. By then energy and skills and power have degraded.
Also, an overlooked and even more important implication is that for all the talk about modern boxers not being able to fight 15 rounds anymore, fighting only 12 rounds actually PENALISES modern boxers somewhat here because if you made modern boxers fight 15 rounds, the KO ratio's would become even higher for them because there would be 3 extra rounds of opportunity for them to score KO's.
"Enough with the games mate! Your messing with the Grand Master!"
Lennox Lewis
Bookmarks