Quote Originally Posted by Gandalf View Post
Makes no sense. Marquez is not a D level fighter. He was pfp elite for years Mayweather just struggled with Maidana so using the same logic he must now be a C level fighter. What exactly is the point of this grading system? Is there a rubrik I can follow? Or are you making it up as you go along?
Gandalf, if its easier for you let's leave the alphabet stuff at the door.

This should not be hard to understand.

Marquez is a legend and a great fighter.

Marquez will always loose against mayweather in the same way they fought AFTER floyds 2 year RETIREMENT.

Manny will always struggle with marquez and could easily get knocked out again like their last fight.

Maidan lost to maywayweather twice even with all the low blows, biting knees, and mma tactics.

Maidana vs marquez would be a good fight but at this stage of marquez career you would have to give the edge to maidana.

Can manny beat maidana? Who knows? Manny was too busy fighting two fighters who would get beat by marquez and maidana.

Now when is someone going to answer this question...out of the common opponents that floyd and manny have fought, which one has had the easier path and you can even give them a nice grading if you want?!

Remember manny fought hatton, Moseley and oscar AFTER floyd..come on, let's hear it!