I'm good with Floyd retiring at 49. He is definitely an ATG, and I can now see a case where people place him in the top 5. The guy dominates anyone 160 and down not named GGG. That being said, his fights just don't excite me now as he wins most of his big fights in boring fashion.

The Manny win was big, but compare his performance and action to his wins over Chico Corrales and Ricky Hatton. Floyd FOUGHT and BEAT those guys in a dominant and EXCITING manner. He's so good he will out point pretty much anyone around his weight, but he won't beat them up or consistently put 3 and 4 punches together at a time. He will win by making the other guy hesitant to fight as well. Not a recipe for excitement/drama.