I hear you Daxx, but if the criteria is strictly on quality across the board there is no way in for gatti.

Maybe the Boxing hall of Fame needs to introduce a second tier so they can allow guys like gatti the credit they deserve. The guy still won titles after all.
A second tier for fighters who gave a lot to the game but didn't reach the giddy heights of the truly GREAT fighters.
Leaving the top tier to the chosen few who show surpassing excellence.