Is Gatti a worthy candidate for the Hall of Fame?

[ICB]

if evander holyfield gets in, then so should gatti

but for the record, i answered no

yes but holyfield was argueably the greatest cruiserweight of all time and he beat mike tyson beat riddick bowe and beat douglas who had just beaten tyson and was hw champion like 4 times wasnt he ??

youre right about the cruiserweight holyfield

but he beat a waay washed up tyson (think ali vs berbick)

one out of 3 vs. bowe (a far superior hw)

was 1-1-1 against john ruiz

was 1-1 against michael moorer

lost to chris byrd

however, if he does go on to win a hw championship again, (he won't) then he absolutely deserves to be in the hof

tell me if this is hall of fame material...............  http://boxrec.com/boxer_display.php?boxer_id=499

the only reason he was hw champ 4 times is because he wasnt successful defending his belt

beat washed up tyson ?? hold on wasnt tyson the one beating everyone in 3 rounds or less and was hw champ at that time and was young yet holyfield lost to bowe and looked shot in that fight and holy was like 40-1 on betting odds or something silly like that so i wouldnt call that a washed up tyson he did excellent against bowe the man was 2 stone heavier 1-1-1 against ruiz is when holy was about 40 and finished same with byrd he lost to moorer but i thought he had problem with hes heart in 1 st fight and pulled shoudler during fight in rematch he beat moorer in 8 rounds