You guys agree with this his 20 P4P list??????

[Pugilistic]

its a pretty good list. i would put jones higher than ali or leonard

[p4pking]

Rocky Marciano in the top 20 is also a joke.

[CutMeMick]

I don't think B-hop belongs above RJJ.

Exactly you all! heh

Hey fair is fair.
Thats just how I see it, and apparently most people do.


Back at 'ya Gyrokai.

[bigragu]

cc

its good to see Joe Louis ranked high.

Rocky Marciano had 43 KO's...not 40.....other than that pretty good list....

[cockey cockney]

Leonard and Duran behind Larry Homes, Joe Louis, Hagler, Hopkins, Jones WTF!

[ICB]

i know mate i dont agree with the list at all

[pacdog]

I think Joe louis desrves to be on the list, but... if he foguht today against light heavies and cruizers hed get destroyed let alone havies

[TheBESTP4P]

would if B-Hop read everything that you guys wrote in here about how he doesnt deserve to be above RJJ and it made him sad so he now wants to fight OLEG for the HW belt just to redeem himself to you guys here on SADDO?

[Violent Demise]

The list is garbage

[X]

Anyone who does lists is:

1. forgets what they put first
2. giving a subjective opinion only
3. unable to compute all the clashes the longer the list is
4. forgets what they put first
5. a sad bastard

[mikeboxing]

Roy Jones before Hopkins!!!,

[tedsares]

Armstrong. Langford and other old timers are not on the list becuase my entry qualifications were for fighters I actually saw fight. I spelled this out in the first paragraph.

[Swice]

I think Mayweather is a talented boxer but why is he on this list? It is way to early in his career for him to be in the Top 20 all time. B Hop before RJJ doesn't make since and where in the world is Willie Pep?

Anytime a list like this is made its going to be argumentative but this list needs major reworking. Rarely do I agree with any article posted on ESB so this doesn't surprise me.

[CrunchTime]

Most of whom listed belongs to Heavyweight

It's a shame the division did not live up to it's roots

Maybe it's just that the old heavies look even better than the smaller guys just because TODAY's HWs are so sorry!!

[CrunchTime]

Any top 20 alltime P4P list WITHOUT HENRY ARMSTRONG is ridiculous!!

He is easily top 3 alltime P4P!!