I really like the top 5. The debate between Pernell and Floyd is endless. I think Pernells defense looked a little better because he used his jab more than Floyd and if Floyd would pop out 40 jabs a round he would look untouchable.

But it's hard to argue anyone on the list. I think any but Toney you could argue was the best of the recent era. Only keeping Toney from potentially top was his lack of quickness, his IQ and skill level is there with anyone.(ring IQ only, dude is not running on all cylinders). Locche deserves mention, that guy was phenomenal.

Good list with sound reasoning