WHO's the GREAAAATEST???

[superheavyrhun]

Yup, very good article, though it is definitely written from an American point of view. I'm sure they could have squeezed in a few Brits or europeans into that list.
However, when it comes to being the greatest, then surely one of the factors that should be considered as a boxer is knowing when to retire at the right time in one's career. If you look at the two fighters who have fought in the past 12 months on that list, they are both old, arguably washed up and would have been much better off throwing in the towel when they were near their peak, rather than sullying their legacies with pointless wins and defeats to fighters they would have whupped when they were at their best.

[Violent Demise]

The greatest fighter I ever saw fight live in person, has to be Roy Jones Jr. Back in the early 90's. It was the MGM in Vegas. Jones destroyed poor Thomas Tate. I think Jones at 160 was unbeatable. By anybody. Rafael Ruleas and Oscar Del La Hoya each fought on that card. I forgot his name, but Del La Hoya opponent actually dropped him before he got stopped.

roy jones is good but no one is unbeatable remember that

He was as close as anyone in the history of the sport would ever get to unbeatable tho

If Jou Louis could be outboxed by Billy Conn, theres plenty of people who would of done him in - I don't think the same could be said for Jones

Honestly I think you'll have a hard time naming a middleweight that he couldn't beat over the course of 12 rounds. Hagler, Hearns, Robinson, Monzon, Lamotta, Hopkins all were inferior

IMO anyway

And your opinion makes great sense. Jones at 160. Who could beat him? Not many, if any.

[ICB]

ill name u some that would give him hell ray leonard tommy hearns marvin hagler sugar ray robinson hope this helps jones is good boxer from what i see but he isnt unbeatable middleweight u know that isnt true

[Tito BHB]

ill name u some that would give him hell ray leonard tommy hearns marvin hagler sugar ray robinson hope this helps jones is good boxer from what i see but he isnt unbeatable middleweight u know that isnt true

i feel he was pretty much unbeatable.. he could have taken some big names at middleweight or super middle!! and plus he had the power in the middleweight division he wasnt AS much of a power puncher a light heavy!
i think a prime bernard hopkins would have beaten roy at middleweight... bhop was supreme
peace

[Violent Demise]

ill name u some that would give him hell ray leonard tommy hearns marvin hagler sugar ray robinson hope this helps jones is good boxer from what i see but he isnt unbeatable middleweight u know that isnt true

At 160 Jones destroys natural welterweights Leonard and Hearns (and I'm a Hearns fan). I think he would out point Hagler pretty easily. Robinson would most likely be his toughest test.

[Violent Demise]

ill name u some that would give him hell ray leonard tommy hearns marvin hagler sugar ray robinson hope this helps jones is good boxer from what i see but he isnt unbeatable middleweight u know that isnt true

i feel he was pretty much unbeatable.. he could have taken some big names at middleweight or super middle!! and plus he had the power in the middleweight division he wasnt AS much of a power puncher a light heavy!
i think a prime bernard hopkins would have beaten roy at middleweight... bhop was supreme
peace

Hopkins had his chance against Jones and lost.

[ICB]

i only see his fights at lhw and he looked superb was he better as middleweight demise ??

[TheBESTP4P]

i only see his fights at lhw and he looked superb was he better as middleweight demise ??

hell yeah he was! middle and super middle more so!!!!!!!!!

[kerry0774]

I cant argue with any of your selections as they are all excellent selections...but I truly believe Michael Spinks belongs in the top 10....First light heavy to win the heavyweight crown and the fact that no one could beat him at light heavy. The loss to Tyson probably tarnishes his great career but that was against Tyson at his destructive best fighting a bloated light heavyweight...and I think that fight should be dismissed as such.

[TheBESTP4P]

I cant argue with any of your selections as they are all excellent selections...but I truly believe Michael Spinks belongs in the top 10....First light heavy to win the heavyweight crown and the fact that no one could beat him at light heavy. The loss to Tyson probably tarnishes his great career but that was against Tyson at his destructive best fighting a bloated light heavyweight...and I think that fight should be dismissed as such.

Kerry have ya first Cool Click on me! always remember who your first was K? wink wink. and welcome to the world of SADDO!