Which fight is worse?

[Master]

the khan fight was worse


IMO khan won nothing, looked too small and his punches had little affect


I hear people say he was winning, I didn't see that at all


in comparison to Friday night Brook won the first two and has a case for the third, the injury ended the fight and although the result probably would have been the same he probably would have lasted 2, 3 or 4 more rounds and probably would have landed a few more solid combinations and won a few more rounds

Brook won round 2 and that was it stop sounding like Hearn

[erics44]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

[Primo Carnera]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

I have to agree with Eric that he had at least a share of other rounds. But I also have to be consistent and say, like I did in the Khan v Canelo fight, it's irrelevant who was winning on points, because it was never going to the cards.

[erics44]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

I have to agree with Eric that he had at least a share of other rounds. But I also have to be consistent and say, like I did in the Khan v Canelo fight, it's irrelevant who was winning on points, because it was never going to the cards.

yep very true


but brook GGG was more of a contest than the khan canelo fight


for a couple of rounds at least brook looked like he would make a fight of it

[Master]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

I have to agree with Eric that he had at least a share of other rounds. But I also have to be consistent and say, like I did in the Khan v Canelo fight, it's irrelevant who was winning on points, because it was never going to the cards.

yep very true


but brook GGG was more of a contest than the khan canelo fight


for a couple of rounds at least brook looked like he would make a fight of it

You could argue, on a neutral venue that Khan was winning his fight and won more rounds.

[erics44]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

I have to agree with Eric that he had at least a share of other rounds. But I also have to be consistent and say, like I did in the Khan v Canelo fight, it's irrelevant who was winning on points, because it was never going to the cards.

yep very true


but brook GGG was more of a contest than the khan canelo fight


for a couple of rounds at least brook looked like he would make a fight of it

You could argue, on a neutral venue that Khan was winning his fight and won more rounds.

I'm a khan fan and wanted khan to win but I don't think he won anything


It was like man against boy


and I thought kel was landing some solid hurtful shots and won the first two, and he had some success in 3 and 4

[Master]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

I have to agree with Eric that he had at least a share of other rounds. But I also have to be consistent and say, like I did in the Khan v Canelo fight, it's irrelevant who was winning on points, because it was never going to the cards.

yep very true


but brook GGG was more of a contest than the khan canelo fight


for a couple of rounds at least brook looked like he would make a fight of it

You could argue, on a neutral venue that Khan was winning his fight and won more rounds.

I'm a khan fan and wanted khan to win but I don't think he won anything


It was like man against boy


and I thought kel was landing some solid hurtful shots and won the first two, and he had some success in 3 and 4

Moot point but Khan was in control whereas Brook was surviving from round 3

[Master]

he won the first, he landed a lot more punches, and solid shots


unless you count a wobble as the automatic loss of a round?

Yes, the wobble showed the impact of GGG's punches.