Quote Originally Posted by Primo Carnera View Post
The way I see it , only 1 fighter, or at best one fighter per division can get a 5 star rating . A loss doesn't stop someone getting the 5 star rating, BUT a loss does mean that a fighter could NEVER be called unbeatable.
That's more about facts and the English language rather than boxing opinion.
2 could possibly rated at 5 in a division if they were unbeaten and considered 50/50. Gonzalez, Cuadras, Inoue for example.

Ward-Kovalev. Does Kovalev rate slightly higher?