Top 10 Middleweights

[p4pking]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

[Spicoli]

I hesitate with a guy who has yet to fight the weight but make exception for Charlo. He seemed overdue for the jump up and has shown solid improvements. Sergiy Derevyanchenko one to watch but at 31 he needs to press the gas.

[Ron Swanson]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

[Master]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

[Ron Swanson]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

I just went through the fight thread and the only people that showed their round by round had Jacobs 9-3. People came in and said they gave it to GGG close but a lot of time has passed and I have not seen anyone say which rounds they gave GGG. So the question remains. Is the fight thread where I am supposed to find this rd by rd or is there another?

[Master]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

I just went through the fight thread and the only people that showed their round by round had Jacobs 9-3. People came in and said they gave it to GGG close but a lot of time has passed and I have not seen anyone say which rounds they gave GGG. So the question remains. Is the fight thread where I am supposed to find this rd by rd or is there another?

My mistake it was on this thread

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-jacobs-3.html

You are right CFH and p4p scored it 9-3 Jacobs, Spicoli stopped scoring as did I after the knockdown.

I gave GGG 1,2,3,4 and 9 for sure.

[TitoFan]

So the # 2 guy on the list is a guy who has never actually fought at the weight.

Makes perfect sense to me.


The incomplete post doesn't say WHO'S top ten they are..... but just goes to show that boxing opinions and a buck will get you a cup of coffee.

Personally, I wouldn't even print this list on a roll of toilet paper.

[oakleyno1]

I'd pick Jacobs to beat Canelo

[Ron Swanson]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

I just went through the fight thread and the only people that showed their round by round had Jacobs 9-3. People came in and said they gave it to GGG close but a lot of time has passed and I have not seen anyone say which rounds they gave GGG. So the question remains. Is the fight thread where I am supposed to find this rd by rd or is there another?

My mistake it was on this thread

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-jacobs-3.html

You are right CFH and p4p scored it 9-3 Jacobs, Spicoli stopped scoring as did I after the knockdown.

I gave GGG 1,2,3,4 and 9 for sure.

So you have him the 3rd where Jacobs landed 9 power punches to 4 from GGG. And was fought in the way Jacobs wanted to fight. Interesting. I think giving GGG 12 and taking away the 3rd rightfully makes more sense.

[Master]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

I just went through the fight thread and the only people that showed their round by round had Jacobs 9-3. People came in and said they gave it to GGG close but a lot of time has passed and I have not seen anyone say which rounds they gave GGG. So the question remains. Is the fight thread where I am supposed to find this rd by rd or is there another?

My mistake it was on this thread

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-jacobs-3.html

You are right CFH and p4p scored it 9-3 Jacobs, Spicoli stopped scoring as did I after the knockdown.

I gave GGG 1,2,3,4 and 9 for sure.

So you have him the 3rd where Jacobs landed 9 power punches to 4 from GGG. And was fought in the way Jacobs wanted to fight. Interesting. I think giving GGG 12 and taking away the 3rd rightfully makes more sense.

Looking back on the thread I wish I did score it and now. I forgot that when I watched it live I thought there was going to be an upset. Watching it again I had GGG firmly winning a close fight. I think it was @J_Undisputed who told me to watch the jab from GGG and it was very under rated but a point scorer for GGG.

[Fenster]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

I just went through the fight thread and the only people that showed their round by round had Jacobs 9-3. People came in and said they gave it to GGG close but a lot of time has passed and I have not seen anyone say which rounds they gave GGG. So the question remains. Is the fight thread where I am supposed to find this rd by rd or is there another?

My mistake it was on this thread

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-jacobs-3.html

You are right CFH and p4p scored it 9-3 Jacobs, Spicoli stopped scoring as did I after the knockdown.

I gave GGG 1,2,3,4 and 9 for sure.

So you have him the 3rd where Jacobs landed 9 power punches to 4 from GGG. And was fought in the way Jacobs wanted to fight. Interesting. I think giving GGG 12 and taking away the 3rd rightfully makes more sense.

"Power punches" are counted as any punch other than a jab. Therefore, a tap is recorded as a power punch.

We can accurately count the amount of punches thrown but not landed, especially not the impact/damage rendered by each blow.

[Spicoli]

Kind of crazy that two of the top 4 guys have never fought in the division, however I'd absolutely pick them over any of the lower ranked guys. I'd have Jacobs at number 2 if solely for the GGG fight, there's a case for giving him the decision there.

I watched that fight again last night and even though I always root for GGG in his fights I see no way to give GGG that fight. I would love to hear anyone explain which 6 rounds they give GGG to give him the decision

We went through this already and the 6 rounds would be recorded in the rbr that was done on the fight. Look it up.

I just went through the fight thread and the only people that showed their round by round had Jacobs 9-3. People came in and said they gave it to GGG close but a lot of time has passed and I have not seen anyone say which rounds they gave GGG. So the question remains. Is the fight thread where I am supposed to find this rd by rd or is there another?

My mistake it was on this thread

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxingfor...-jacobs-3.html

You are right CFH and p4p scored it 9-3 Jacobs, Spicoli stopped scoring as did I after the knockdown.

I gave GGG 1,2,3,4 and 9 for sure.

Thinking back I believe I had Jacobs by a single point. Have them written down somewhere so need to check. Have to say I was so far off the mark on the fight and Jacobs being 'destroyed' and still need a rewatch.