My top ten P4P list....

[Primo Carnera]

underrated maybe, but over rated too

on each occasion below he had the advantages

I know what you're saying, but you can't be underrated and overrated at the same time.
And he did have the advantages , home town etc. But the biggest advantage he had was that he was better.

maybe

but would he have won all those fights fighting away?

Maybe, maybe not. Personally I think he would've, but it's a fair point. All I would say is if Ward isn't number 1, who is?