Who's The Best

[Master]

The funk you waffling bout Eric?

Leonard and Roy both fought at middleweight.

Leonard and Floyd both fought at welter.

Therefore, Leonard could have met both of them.

Leonard lost to a lightweight, a pomp Roy would never lose to a fighter 2 weights below him

Leonard would lose to Floyd at welterweight

Leonard would lose to Roy at middleweight

Leonard lost to a great former lightweight and avenged that loss.

still lost to a lightweight

who lost to every other half decent fighter he fought about lightweight

that alone puts Leonard last on this list

Duran was one of, if the not the best lightweight in history, just because he lost does not mean they are not better than Floyd. Zero on a record does not mean you are the best, otherwise Sven Ottke would be one of the greatest champions of all time.

[erics44]

Duran was an exceptional lightweight

but lets be honest he won little above lightweight, leonard was his best win by a million miles

[Master]

Duran was an exceptional lightweight

but lets be honest he won little above lightweight, leonard was his best win by a million miles

To show how great Duran was past his best weight he beat undefeated Leonard (welterweight title), Moore (super welterweight title), took Hagler to points and beat Barkley for middleweight title being under 40. Amazing.

[erics44]

Duran was an exceptional lightweight

but lets be honest he won little above lightweight, leonard was his best win by a million miles

To show how great Duran was past his best weight he beat undefeated Leonard (welterweight title), Moore (super welterweight title), took Hagler to points and beat Barkley for middleweight title being under 40. Amazing.

yeah he did well, still would never have beaten Floyd or Jones

and he beat Leonard

[Primo Carnera]

Duran was an exceptional lightweight

but lets be honest he won little above lightweight, leonard was his best win by a million miles

To show how great Duran was past his best weight he beat undefeated Leonard (welterweight title), Moore (super welterweight title), took Hagler to points and beat Barkley for middleweight title being under 40. Amazing.

yeah he did well, still would never have beaten Floyd or Jones

and he beat Leonard

Ok, would Duran have beaten Floyd at lightweight in your opinion?

[Master]

Duran was an exceptional lightweight

but lets be honest he won little above lightweight, leonard was his best win by a million miles

To show how great Duran was past his best weight he beat undefeated Leonard (welterweight title), Moore (super welterweight title), took Hagler to points and beat Barkley for middleweight title being under 40. Amazing.

yeah he did well, still would never have beaten Floyd or Jones

and he beat Leonard

Leonard also beat him in the return.