Quote Originally Posted by Master View Post
James Toney spectacularly knocked out Williams but I would not say it was a beating. I think Toney gave Barkley a worse beating that he did Charles.
Agree that the Barkley beating was worse, but feel that Williams took a consistent pounding for 11+ rounds before that horrific right/knock out. Similar to Roy vs. Glen Johnson, where Roy/Williams had a few moments and threw some back, but took pretty consistent punishment round after round (for many rounds) before getting stopped by a big shot. Barkley was taken apart by Toney and that fight pretty much ended his career at that level.