Quote Originally Posted by Master View Post
Quote Originally Posted by mikeeod View Post
When discussing robberies we usually focus on bad judges, but what about referees that have inserted themselves into fights to the point that they decided the outcomes? Some examples I can think of:

1. G-Man vs. Benn: Don’t want to offend my British friends so I will admit potential bias, but I remember the ref literally holding McLellan back after putting Benn through the ropes and providing Nigel with a few crucial extra seconds to clear his head. I also felt Benn got away with a ridiculous number of rabbit punches throughout the fight.

2. Floyd vs. Ricky Hatton: I feel that Ricky’s best chance was to fight inside and maul Floyd, not the prettiest tactic but his only shot at winning. I remember the ref constantly admonishing/warning Ricky and affecting the way he fought.

3. Chavez vs. Meldrick Taylor: I think Richard Steele was a great ref and I don’t think his last second stoppage was ill intentioned. That being said, that call cost Taylor more than just his belt and that fight. Maybe Meldrick ends up damaged goods regardless, but he at least deserved to have that win after leaving such a big part of himself in that ring.
Benn fell through the ropes so G Man had to be held back.
If you watch the fight again you will see that Benn is back in the ring but still out of it. Gerald continually tries to go after him and finish him off and the ref pushes him back multiple times while looking back to make sure Benn has his wits about him. Even the commentators mention it. One of them aka what the hell the ref is doing....

I may be biased though, so watch for yourself and make up your own mind.