Should transgenered people be allowed to box?

[TitoFan]

It's really a moot point, because it would never happen. Nobody in their right mind would sanction such a fight, and Loma himself would probably rather smack himself around than fighting a woman.

But for the sake of the argument, Loma would win by scary and damaging knockout.

@TitoFan.....

Your point is the 'moot' one as my point was hypothetical and therefore looking for opinions with valid and relevant arguments therefore I reiterate, they are in the ring together, the bell goes... who wins and why?

Sensible and relevant answers only please.

#MSGG

Is it something in the water over there??

My second sentence answered the question. Why? 'Cause he's a man with all the natural anatomical advantages men have... that's why.

Happy?

[smashup]

It's really a moot point, because it would never happen. Nobody in their right mind would sanction such a fight, and Loma himself would probably rather smack himself around than fighting a woman.

But for the sake of the argument, Loma would win by scary and damaging knockout.

@TitoFan.....

Your point is the 'moot' one as my point was hypothetical and therefore looking for opinions with valid and relevant arguments therefore I reiterate, they are in the ring together, the bell goes... who wins and why?

Sensible and relevant answers only please.

#MSGG

Is it something in the water over there??

My second sentence answered the question. Why? 'Cause he's a man with all the natural anatomical advantages men have... that's why.

Happy?

@TitoFan

What would make me happy is if you answered the question with proven facts... for instance can you provide and explain what anatomical advantages a man of the same height and weight dimensions as a woman would have in a boxing capacity.... (Your kick boxing/thai theory has no relevance.}

So I'll ask again... who wins and why and just because Loma is male please explain how this gives him the advantage over Taylor.

I believe if they are matched in weight and skill it's a 50/50 fight regardless of gender.... can you provide some evidence (boxing only) as to why this isn't the case?

#MSGG

[palmerq]

This thread is starting to remind me of another long running thread :S...

[Fenster]

Why is this stickied? It gets more and more mental on here everyday

[palmerq]

I assumed it was because you usually sticky fight threads and this one is well on track to being a fight thread in its own way.

[Fenster]

I clicked on it thinking it was the Bivol-Smith rd-by-rd, took a second to realise where I was.

[powerpuncher]

Who wants to fight me?