Quote Originally Posted by JonesJrMayweather
yeah floyd does say that...but turning pro at sixteen? risking losses that obviously are costing him big dollars now...roy had been at LH for 6years before he fought tarver...not to mention he came down from HW in the first fight...if margarito was to beat mayweather he suddenly top 10 p4p? how is that fair? he could have had many amateur fights from 16-19...then turned pro at 20, but what's done is done...i'm sorry if i offended you...by asking "does it make him coward? and putting what a biitch" i just don't think he's done anything except beat another up and comer in cintron...which obviously wasn't big enough for him to be worth a fight...and there is a significant risk for floyd fighting a bigger man, even bigger than judah regardless of how much better PBF is than him...why do you think that judah/mayweather is more money..because at least judah did fight someone worth talking about KT, spinks was the undisputed WW champ, when judah beat him period..he had all the belts and judah stopped him...spinks did beat mayorga, something vernon forrest couldn't do in two fights..and he beat shane twice....i know the "beat the man philosophy" is sour to some but it does speak volumes as to your resume of fight competition's ability....
Tarver's clearly a bigger guy than RJ, just look at them side by side, Tarver's naturally about 205 and he takes off weight to make 175, RJ walks around at about 185, not to mention being shorter, Tarver's a bigger guy whether Roy fought at LH for a while or even HWs

Not the point though, Margarito would and should get credit for beating PBF. There are other bigger guys that I mentioned, like ODLH and Shane, even Zab who actually started at a higher weight than either ODLH or Shane although ODLH was a huge lightweight. Just cause he's bigger than Floyd naturally doesn't mean he would get no credit for beating him for it. And as far as P4P, most people would put Margarito somewhere in the bottom half for beating Floyd, Floyd's number 1 P4P, thought of as almost invulnerable, and if Hatton can get in off the Tsyzu win, and very little else, and Tarver could be as high as like 3 or 4 on the RJ win, and not a whole lot besides that, then Margrito with beating PBF and having 1 loss in the last 10 years would get in the bottom half IMO.

Not offended, just disagreed with you cause IMO its not his fault that those guys didn't fight him

Judah may well be more deserving based on his one win over Spinks, even though I think Margarito would beat Judah, he clearly would have been if he hadn't gotten beaten by a 9 loss journeyman in his last fight and almost been knocked out. It's bad for Margarito to lose to a 9 loss guy early in his career when he was 18 but Judah loss to a nine loss guy in his last fight, how can you blow the set up fight to the biggest fight of your life like that? But its not totally surprising, this is a guy that had to go to split decision against Rafeal Pineda who's like 803 years old.

But that wasn't my point from the beginning, I wasn't comparing PBF and Margarito, I just disagreed with you in your original post. I'd like to see Margarito-PBF, why not its an intriguing fight. I'd probably rather see PBF-Hatton, I'm gonna wait and see what ODLH shows versus Mayorga cause he's so inactive and he's a bit past it so I don't know really know what he has. Even PBF-Shane's not bad, but I'd like to see PBF-Margarito too. IMO I just don't see any reason to not want intriguing fights to happen.