Your personal P4P 1 with their best three wins?

[Baal]

P4P 1 - Inoue
Top 3 wins - Rodriguez, Payano, Narvaez

[TitoFan]

P4P 1 - Inoue
Top 3 wins - Rodriguez, Payano, Narvaez

I'll go with this one. No contest.

[palmerq]

P4p number one, Saul Alvarez.

Best wins, Cotto, golovkin, jacobs............

[Master]

P4p number one, Saul Alvarez.

Best wins, Cotto, golovkin, jacobs............

There is always someone who is not taking the thread seriously.

[powerpuncher]

I just realized that I might have missed the point. Are we picking who we think is the best p4p fighter and picking their three best wins? Or are we picking someone with the three best wins in boxing at the moment?

[Master]

I just realized that I might have missed the point. Are we picking who we think is the best p4p fighter and picking their three best wins? Or are we picking someone with the three best wins in boxing at the moment?

The former.

[Fenster]

I just realized that I might have missed the point. Are we picking who we think is the best p4p fighter and picking their three best wins? Or are we picking someone with the three best wins in boxing at the moment?

Pacquiao would occupy every spot 1-10.

It's funny as the most important aspect to boxing is "who you beat," right? Everyone (who follows boxing) is in agreement. However, just look how "weak" the current P4P looks?

So far from 20 fighters named, only Canelo has beat two certain HOFamers, nobody else has beaten one.

[Fenster]

Imagine you were then asked to name the three best wins of the opponents?

[powerpuncher]

I just realized that I might have missed the point. Are we picking who we think is the best p4p fighter and picking their three best wins? Or are we picking someone with the three best wins in boxing at the moment?

Pacquiao would occupy every spot 1-10.

It's funny as the most important aspect to boxing is "who you beat," right? Everyone (who follows boxing) is in agreement. However, just look how "weak" the current P4P looks?

So far from 20 fighters named, only Canelo has beat two certain HOFamers, nobody else has beaten one.

I think we are in a good place in boxing right now where there are a lot of really good fighters. I do agree though that their competition isn’t near what fighters from the past were. It’s unfortunate that a lot of these fighters aren’t getting career defining fights. Sometimes it is their fault but sometimes it isn’t.

[powerpuncher]

P4p number one, Saul Alvarez.

Best wins, Cotto, golovkin, jacobs............

There is always someone who is not taking the thread seriously.

I guess “wins” is a relative term around here

[TitoFan]

P4p number one, Saul Alvarez.

Best wins, Cotto, golovkin, jacobs............

There is always someone who is not taking the thread seriously.

TitoFan liked this post

[imp]

Khan.

Maidana. Billy Dib. Devon Alexander.

[Kirkland Laing]

P4P 1 - Inoue
Top 3 wins - Rodriguez, Payano, Narvaez

I'll go with this one. No contest.

Me too.

[Baal]

P4P 1 - Inoue
Top 3 wins - Rodriguez, Payano, Narvaez

I'll go with this one. No contest.

In my opinion, the distance between Inoue and Usyk is very close. @Fenster did you reveal your list?

[Primo Carnera]

Fair play, Fenny, this is a really interesting thread.
My p4p #1 would be either Crawford or Inoue. But if you put AJ’s best 3 wins (Wlad, Povetkin and Parker Whyte.) then If you judged it with this formula, that would stack up pretty well against Crawford.
But would you put AJ above Crawford? Like I said, it’s interesting.