i wasn't really ever sold on Spaddy the way he struggled against Dorin and how easy Gatti beat him made me really wonder just how good he really is, that said i think he wouldn't really have a chance at either division, well not against the top competition anyways,

at 135
Julio Diaz
Juan Diaz
Joel Casamayor
Jorge Barrios
Acelino Freitas
Jesus Chavez
Jose Cotto

at 140
Ricky Hatton
Juan Urango
Junior Witter
Arturo Gatti
Paul Malignaggi
Jose Luis Castillo
Diego Corrales

all would probably take him