I think the weight division which both Roy and Tommy were closest to in prime would supermiddleweight, but you are right, they just do not match up at the same weight class as prime. Oddly enough now. Tommy and Roy are at the same weight class. Tommy weighed in 176 in his last fight last Feb, and Roy is 175. But at this point even though Roy is on the downside, Hearns I heard looks terrible with the guys he fought the last two years. And these are guys who really wouldn't have been his sparring partners before. I would have to pick Roy now.. But in the past, I think Tommy's style was good to beat Roy.