NOW can we stop the disrespect on Crawford and put him at #1 p4p?

[Master]

Josh is undisputed at the weight and still remains undefeated. One bad fight should not take away all the good work he has done in his career.

One question. If Catterall was given the decision, would you still be ok with Josh Taylor at #5 ?

No, he would be down maybe even out of the top 10.

[Primo Carnera]

Josh is undisputed at the weight and still remains undefeated. One bad fight should not take away all the good work he has done in his career.

One question. If Catterall was given the decision, would you still be ok with Josh Taylor at #5 ?

No, he would be down maybe even out of the top 10.

There you go.

[Primo Carnera]

Josh is undisputed at the weight and still remains undefeated. One bad fight should not take away all the good work he has done in his career.

One question. If Catterall was given the decision, would you still be ok with Josh Taylor at #5 ?

No, he would be down maybe even out of the top 10.

Next question, did you think Taylor beat Catterall?

[Master]

Josh is undisputed at the weight and still remains undefeated. One bad fight should not take away all the good work he has done in his career.

One question. If Catterall was given the decision, would you still be ok with Josh Taylor at #5 ?

No, he would be down maybe even out of the top 10.

Next question, did you think Taylor beat Catterall?

Catterall should have got the decision.

[Primo Carnera]

Josh is undisputed at the weight and still remains undefeated. One bad fight should not take away all the good work he has done in his career.

One question. If Catterall was given the decision, would you still be ok with Josh Taylor at #5 ?

No, he would be down maybe even out of the top 10.

Next question, did you think Taylor beat Catterall?

Catterall should have got the decision.

So you think Taylor lost his last fight, which , regardless of the decision, wouldn’t be particularly impressive.
Certainly not impressive enough to be called one of the 5 best boxers on the planet at any weight, wouldn’t you agree?
Look, I’ve written on here many times before, that P4P is a pathetic concept.
All it is good for is to work out the best 2 or 3 boxers on the planet. Start going any deeper than that and it borders on the ridiculous.

[Master]

Josh is undisputed at the weight and still remains undefeated. One bad fight should not take away all the good work he has done in his career.

One question. If Catterall was given the decision, would you still be ok with Josh Taylor at #5 ?

No, he would be down maybe even out of the top 10.

Next question, did you think Taylor beat Catterall?

Catterall should have got the decision.

So you think Taylor lost his last fight, which , regardless of the decision, wouldn’t be particularly impressive.
Certainly not impressive enough to be called one of the 5 best boxers on the planet at any weight, wouldn’t you agree?
Look, I’ve written on here many times before, that P4P is a pathetic concept.
All it is good for is to work out the best 2 or 3 boxers on the planet. Start going any deeper than that and it borders on the ridiculous.

True, it is very subjective and can be open to supporting your favourite fighter's. Josh got very lucky and he could have been more humble but he is still the champion. I thought Golovkin beat Canelo twice but officially it was a draw and loss.

I agree with you on Crawford.