Quote Originally Posted by p4pking
I don't think Calzaghe would win, he's too small and isn't as good against counter punchers.. Also I don't know one good southpaw he has ever fought.. Could be wrong, but that's a big intangible if this fight ever were to happen.
you question calzaghe's chance against tarver because of his size and yet you think hopkins has a much more reasonable chance against tarver....remember calzaghe is a large supermiddle weight...a jump up to light heavy is nothing too big...

and remember calzaghe is in his prime, fighting 3 minutes of every round....tarver struggled at times with a gun shy and shot jones jr....

calzaghe has a good chance of beating this 37 year old tarver...