So who's the male tennis GOAT?

[TitoFan]

Great news. Plus Novak's younger than Nadal... so there's little danger of Rafa catching back up.

[Mark TKO]

Djok could easily get to 26 as there doesn't seem to be a consistent youngster coming through.

I'd still put Fed as the GOAT mind

[TitoFan]

Djok could easily get to 26 as there doesn't seem to be a consistent youngster coming through.

I'd still put Fed as the GOAT mind

I'm a big Fed fan, so I agree. If forced to rank the "Big Three" in terms of GOAT (with a personal bias)... I'd rank them like this:

1. Federer
2. Novak
3. Nadal

[Mark TKO]

I wrote earlier in the thread how I see all four slams going in a season with them all at their peak.

And I'll repeat something else that I said re Borg being overlooked when it comes to the GOAT

[TitoFan]

I'd put Rod Laver ahead of Borg. Borg's got no Australian or US Opens. Laver has at least two of each of the majors, plus matches Borg in career majors wins.

[Mark TKO]

Imo there was tougher opposition in the Borg era.

He only played for 9 seasons and entered the Australian just once. Fair comment on the US open wins but Borg was up against Connors and Mcenroe who were better on that surface eg like Fed with the French because of Nadal. He got to 4 finals.

11 slams and 5 finals in 8 seasons when he only played three of them (didn't enter the French one year when at his peak) and walked away aged 25.

That's some going

[Mark TKO]

Actually I just read up - he had just gone 26 when he walked away.

27 slams entered and won 11 of them with 5 runner ups. Surely Djok isn't close to those stats - though there is the longevity with him

[TitoFan]

Imo there was tougher opposition in the Borg era.

He only played for 9 seasons and entered the Australian just once. Fair comment on the US open wins but Borg was up against Connors and Mcenroe who were better on that surface eg like Fed with the French because of Nadal. He got to 4 finals.

11 slams and 5 finals in 8 seasons when he only played three of them (didn't enter the French one year when at his peak) and walked away aged 25.

That's some going

Cases can be made for both. But here's a quote from Wiki on Rod Laver:

"Rodney George Laver AC MBE (born 9 August 1938 ) is an Australian former tennis player. Laver was the world number 1 ranked professional in some sources in 1964, in all sources from 1965 to 1969 and in some sources in 1970, spanning four years before and three years after the start of the Open Era in 1968. He was also ranked the world number 1 amateur in 1961 by Lance Tingay and 1962 by Tingay and Ned Potter. Laver's 198 singles titles are the most in tennis history. This included his all-time men's record of 10 or more titles per year for seven consecutive years (1964–1970). He excelled on all of the court surfaces of his time: grass, clay, hard, carpet, wood.

Laver won 11 Grand Slam singles titles, though he was banned from playing those tournaments for the five years prior to the Open Era. Laver is the only player, male or female, to win the Grand Slam (winning all four major titles in the same calendar year) twice in singles, in 1962 and 1969; the latter remains the only time a man has done so in the Open Era. He is the first male player out of two to be winner and runner up at all four grand slams, followed by Roger Federer. He is the second of four male players to win each major title twice (preceded by Roy Emerson and followed by Novak Djokovic and Rafael Nadal). Laver also won 8 Pro Slam titles, including the "pro Grand Slam" in 1967, and he contributed to five Davis Cup titles for Australia during an age when the Davis Cup was deemed as significant as the four majors. The Laver Cup tournament and the Rod Laver Arena are named after him."

The "competition" argument should be taken with a grain of salt. A lot of it is relative. Borg had McEnroe and Connors to contend with. In Laver's era there was Ken Rosewall and Pancho Gonzales. Unknowns to most of us... both nevertheless formidable opponents to Laver.

My thing continues to be that I can't rate surface specialists. That's why I've always shied away from putting Nadal anywhere near the top of any GOAT lists. The great ones win on all surfaces.