Thanks: 2
Likes: 23
Dislikes: 0
Array
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
Array
I sort of see your point in that 1994 was the year of Camacho, Campas, and Carr.
But then I went through each year of The Ring Magazine's annual ratings from 1994 to 1999, and didn't see any names in the top ten that would've given Trinidad much trouble.
The three names I see that people talk about wishing had been matched against Trinidad are: Quartey, Mosley, and Forrest.
Yeah... it's too bad Trinidad didn't face any of those three. They would've been good fights.
However, you look at his record from the time he won that first championship, and you come away with a pretty good list of names.
But sure... his already super-impressive resume would've looked even better had he faced and beaten any of those three names.
Array
Array
tito won the ibf belt in ninety-three, ninety-four was a brilliant year for him, then ninety-five to ninety-eight was four years wasted. pernell whitaker is the obvious one, he was there from ninety-three, they didn’t fight until ninety-nine. ike quartey was there from ninety-three, they never fought. jose luis lopez won the wbo belt in ninety-six, they never fought. oscar de la hoya was there from ninety-seven, they didn’t fight until ninety-nine. shane mosley didn’t move to welter until ninety-nine. vernon forrest only really became a contender around ninety-nine, so they are not really in the timeframe I am discussing
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
Array
Array
So Tito should have faced Quartey and Lopez as well as Sweat Pea who were champions?
All of the belt holders never unified and were to blame. Not until Oscar came up and rocked the cartel did things start to happen.
Pernell Whitaker was recognised as the best for me at the weight at that time.
Do not let success go to your head and do not let failure get to your heart.
Array
Do not let success go to your head and do not let failure get to your heart.
Array
I believe Trinidad was the longest reigning welterweight champion in history, with the second most title defenses at that weight.
Yes... a fight against Quartey would've been a hell of a fight, as Ike was one of the greats at that time also.
He then moved up to light middleweight like you said, @Master ...at which he had what is still my favorite fight of all time... his TKO over Fernando Vargas.
Then unlike Oscar, who made an ill-fated attempt at 160 only to get knocked out by a BHop liver shot... Trinidad knocked out highly regarded WBA champion William Joppy, before losing to BHop by 12th round TKO himself.
Array
Did not realise that Tito secured that many defences at Welterweight but that is another good sign that he took on the best fighters at the weight. Loved Tito beating undefeated contenders like Oba Carr and Campus who caused Trinidad a lot of problems.
Tito v Jose Luis Lopez would have been a belter!!
To be fair to Oscar he started at the lower weights so going up past Welterweight was harder for him. Vargas was a favourite fighter of mine and both Tito and Oscar beat him in brilliant contests.
To be fair to Trinidad going past light middle was harder for him and he got beat by Winky as well as B Hop and Roy Jones.
Do not let success go to your head and do not let failure get to your heart.
Array
Good point about Oscar. IMO, he had no business going up to middle, and I don't even count the fight against Felix Sturm.
Now that you mention Vargas against both Trinidad and Oscar...
One thing you also may not realize is a lot of common opponents for both Tito and Oscar first faced Tito. They lost by KO, and THEN they faced Oscar.
At least in Fernando's case, you might say Oscar beat a lesser, damaged version of the fighter Tito faced first.
The list includes:
Mayorga - lost to Tito by TKO (2004), then to Oscar by TKO (2006)
Campas - undefeated when he lost to Tito by TKO (1994), had 5 losses when he lost by TKO to Oscar (2003)
Carr - undefeated when he lost to Tito by TKO (1994), had 2 losses when he lost by TKO to Oscar (1999)
Camacho - past his prime, but lost to Tito by wide UD (1994), even further past his prime when he lost by UD to Oscar (1997)
Then there's Fernando himself. Lost by TKO to Tito (2000), then by TKO again to Oscar (2002)
Besides Campas and Carr, who were undefeated when going up against Trinidad, the other undefeated fighters Tito handed their first defeat included:
Oscar and Fernando themselves, and David Reid.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Bookmarks