I say Mayweather by at least a 116-112 margin on all 3 cards. I'm not sold on Oscar's fitness/speed at this stage of his career. He looked spectacular against Mayorga, but that doesn't really prove much, except that he's not really really shot.

I don't think even a prime Oscar would have the speed and timing to break down Floyd's defense--no way a 2007 Oscar does.

Have to agree that this fight will lack fireworks though. I see Floyd dodging most of everything and potshotting Oscar enough to take the majority of the rounds.