Quote Originally Posted by THE Bigragu
Quote Originally Posted by CityOfGod
Let's be real here.

Who is Quintana? he was fighting 8 rounders last year.

Then beat a 'prospect' to become catapulted into this fight.

When cotto fights a P4P top 10 fighter like Mayweather, Hatton or Castillo - then he'll get mad props....... but til then, let's not go over the top.
I think you're on to something here.....He has yet to face someone that has "The Cred".....until then the Jury is still out.....I don't think he has the ability to hang with the likes of PBF and he is way to big for Hatton....
The bolded is exactly why I think Hatton has no business being rated higher than Cotto on any P4P. If Cotto were to move back down or Hatton back up, Cotto would destroy him. And how fighters would fare against each other fighting at the same division (so long as it's not seriously a unnatural weight for them) is pretty much what P4P is all about.