Quote Originally Posted by The Grinch
Ooh, this IS a toughie...
As much as i would like to say RJJ runs away with it, i really cant be so sure.

I mean, it all comes down to effectiveness and activity.

Roy has the footwork, hand-speed & power advantages to put his plan in action but Winkys defenece would make RJJ's attacks look ineffective for large portions of the fight.

I say large portions but Roy dosen't really throw the sort of numbers Winky can.

Also, apart from his fleety foot-work, Roy has no defence. So with Winky pressing in the unique way that he does, its a fair comment to say that he'd continuously be in scoring range while not actually walking onto anything.... Worse still he could even make Roy look negative, reduce his numbers or make him fight at an uncomfortable pace and tire him out.

With that said, it could be obvious to some just how much im overlooking Roy's talents here. Thats only because its easy to assume Roy would dominate given his naturally superior physical attributes and abilities.

But attributes aside... Its styles... and skills that makes fights.

Despite what ive just said, im gonna go with Roy via UD but if they had ever met at 160 and Winky had won, i wouldnt of been suprised.
roy has no defence because no one can hit him he is too quick its like herol graham all over again ahhh :P