Quote Originally Posted by spine_buster
What if?

again

WHAT IF?

Pac vs MAB= Pac KO'd Barrera
PBF vs Oscar= PBF outboxes Oscar in a convincing UD


Then whose No. 1
We have to see if they do anything else in 2007, if they both retire after that we'd have to look at their accomplishments.

PAC - Titles at Flyweight, Super Bantam, Feather, Super Feather

Notable wins: MAB (would be twice in your scenario), Erik Morales (twice), Oscar Larios, 3K Battery

Record: 44-3-2 (35 KOs) (again assuming your scenario)

PBF - Titles at Super Featherweight, Lightweight, Light Welterweight, Welterweight and Light Middleweight (based on your scenario)

Notable wins: ODLH, Judah, Gatti, Castillo (twice), Corrales, Baldomir, Mitchell, Chavez

Record: 38-0-0 (24 KOs) (assuming your scenario)

Given just these fights I would have PBF at #1 with PAC right behind him, however if PAC follows up with pretty much anything, I would give it to him.