Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
You know I looooove Cotto but compared to the guys on the list,all of whom have at least 1 super name that stands out,Cotto does not have that...yet.....if he beats Tony next year and another good name,he'll be super high in the list.
Agreed there. Good point...but I still rank him based on his accomplishments & the fact that he's undefeated.

Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
Why don't you see JLC there though,becaue of the weight stuff? Look past that,he has a great resume....
I used to rank Castillo. Used to think that he was a great fighter...but he seems to be slipping to me & there are much better men out there, with much better opposition, with much better performances, & much more deserving.

Very surprised that you don't have Juan Manuel in there...other than the Chris John farce of a decision...he's been dead on the money.