Quote Originally Posted by OumaFan
1)PBF-Good resume, not the best but good, plus I just think he's the best
2)Winky-Tough call between him and Pac, they've both fought great comp, maybe Pac's is better lately, but Winky hasn't been clearly beaten since Vazquez a long time ago
3)Pac-Could be two, hell, could be one
4)MAB-more on accomplishments now, not totally sure he's a top five fighter anymore but still a great fighter plus all the great wins
5)Castillo-I've said time and again I don't see how he's not on the upper half of everybody's list. Great accomplishments, great fighter. If it wasn't for the inactivity, he might be 4th
6)Taylor-Must be doing something right, three very competitive fights with two of the best. Good fighter whether I like him or not.
7)Rafael Marquez-Doesn't have the accomplishments of the top six but a great fighter with some good to great wins.
Joel Casamayor-Could easily make a case that he's undefeated against great opposition.
9)Ricky Hatton-Slipping a bit but still there
10)JMM-Honestly didn't know who to put here. I have a problem putting JMM on cause he doesn't have a great win, I thought he lost to Pac. Still a great fighter, and you could make a case he won the Pac fight, or at least deserved a draw.

Missed the cut

Calzaghe-Just doesn't make the fights. A waste of great talent.
Corrales-Just think he's kind of done, but you could make a case for a spot for him
Lorenzo Parra-Needs one more good to great win, great fighter though.
Joan Guzman-Again, needs a big win, but has the talent to someday make the list
Cotto-Honestly surprised at the votes for Cotto. I've come around and officially become a fan but even though he's undefeated, you have to look at the competition, its good solid competition but its not P4P level.
James Toney-A clear cut win over Peter, I thought the first was clear cut but oh well, along with all his accomplishments would be enough.
Israel Vazquez-Beat Rafael Marquez and he'd be clearly on there. Without a doubt.
Calderon-You know, he's great, but he needs a big time opponent to make the step up.

Sure I'm forgetting some, Hopkins would be on, but I'll see what's going on with him first.
Nice. Dead on the money as usual.