Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
You're right Wack,I think I should have JMM there somewhere but where?? He does not have the big name he needs yet,like Cotto. But maaaaaaaaan,is it me or could that P4P list be like TOTALLY different by the end of next year,I mean most of those guys are fighting each other!!!!
Marquez, IWO, deserves the right to be on the P4P list due to the fact that he's been on it before...& not just ours...I can't see knocking him off based on a hometown decision...but this is the forum's list...not mine.

Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
WACK,I disagree with JLC,wins over SteviE jOnston,giving PBF his toughest fight,KTFO cORRALES,beat Casamayor,lAzacano,Diaz,that's ALOT of goood names there my man.
Got KTFO by Corrales too. Agreed that there are good names on his resume...but I dunno...I just don't dig.

Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
I disagree with anyone that puts B Hop on their list,because I just don'r rate Tarver and I can't have him there after he lost twice to JT.oNE DAY THE MAN is retired,the next he comes back,that's annoying. And SHZA,you know you're one of ym fave posters BUT NO NO NO WAY does SSM make the list. 2 wins over a shot Vargas does NOT qualify you for p4p! No way! And we'll see if he dominates 147,people keep thinking this is the Shane and the WW division of old,it's not,there are young lions like Cotto,slicksters like Collazo,powerhouses like Cintron and just pure power punching machines like Williams and of course,Tony. A win over Vargas is in no way an indicator he would bea ANY of these guys.
As far as Bernard goes...I'm shocked to here that. He was running 20-0 until the first debacle of the Taylor fight...came back & beat the #1 175er. If he aint retired...then I say he deserves it...but then again...it's the forum's list...not mine.

Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
I forgot Casamayor,he's close though.
No way in hell on that one babe. I can flex on the others...but I can't agree with you on him.