Quote Originally Posted by Gun Tommy
Wlad - destroying Byrd and Brock should definitely get you on the top (what else should get on the list?)
Good fighter. Argueably the best of the heavyweight division...but beating Brock & Byrd doesn't get you on top of any list. Byrd won very poor fights against some lack lustre opponents & got some decisions that he shouldn't have won. Brock was unproven & had fought no one of merit & was rushed in with someone way above his league.

Quote Originally Posted by Gun Tommy
Maywether - he is just so good and would be no1 if he fought better opposition.
Mayweather is #1 on the list. He's fought damned good opposition too.

Quote Originally Posted by Gun Tommy
Jermain Taylor - sole based on results - IMO he would clearly loose to both Calzaghe and especially Kessler
Taylor? He deserves a spot on the list because of his wins...even though they are a bit controversial...he did indeed win...or atleast get the decisions...I don't think that Calzaghe or Kessler will be a factor because Taylor has now stated he won't move up. He's got more important fights than that..Abraham, Miranda, Pavlik, & more await him @ 160lbs.

Quote Originally Posted by Gun Tommy
Calzaghe - just talent but not doing well with it....
Yep. Undefeated with record defenses & the top fighter of his division...yep. Hands down he deserves a spot.

Quote Originally Posted by Gun Tommy
Manny Pac - extremely overrated but did just okay in 2006
Absolutely. He did more than just okay in 2006.

Quote Originally Posted by Gun Tommy
agree?
Not really...but that's what the voting is for & voicing opinions from pillar to post.

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxing_fo...c,40560.0.html

The top three P4P fighters have been voted on by the forum if your'e interested in getting involved.