Quote Originally Posted by Gyrokai
Unknown, wow, they make you! And number two is still two high! haha

I say Pacquiao is number one, but Winky at number one, with his dominance and consistency has earned his respect, even if I'm not a big fan of Winky you can't deny him his status. Here's a quote from Doug Fischer, in case anyone wants the...
Cliff Notes from Gyrokai.


BUT I do think it's telling that the two best fighters Mayweather has fought since JL Castillo - Zab and Chop Chop - were both coming off losses.

Wow, nice quote from Dougie! Go get'em Dougie!
I used to not like this guy, Fischer, now I understand that he bases all his arguments on reason. He also admits when he's wrong. I don't agree with him all the time, I even met him after the Morales Pacquiao I fight, and told him, to his face, that
"I don't agree with you all the time." haha

Check this out:
You ask if “there is a dispute that Judah has the physical ability to give Mayweather a better fight than Bruseles, N'Dou, Gatti or Mitchell gave him?”

No, there isn’t; but isn’t that an indictment on the quality of PBF’s opposition over the past three years?

Another brilliant move by the Dougster. Just give the man his PhD!
And here's another quote on his opposition:
Beyond Hatton (who isn’t ready to fight PBF this year) and Margarito (who was born ready), don’t you think that Joel Casamayor, Julio Diaz, Acelino Freitas, Junior Witter, Vivian Harris, Juan Lazcano, and even Lovemore Ndou ALSO have the physical ability (as well as the experience and skills) to give PBF a better fight than Bruseles, Ndou, Gatti or Mitchell?

And finally, the killer quote:
Real fans want to see good fights – period.

Ooohhhhh!
Agree with wanting to see good fights. Did I like seeing Floyd fight Mitchell or even Gatti? Hell no, and I don't even want to mention the other guys name. Pac stay at three for one simple fact, regardless of comp, Floyd has no losses. Pac has a draw and a loss, granted they were against top guys, in his last few fights." What have you done for me lately ",always plays a key role in the p4p rankings. So does career though. If it didn't, why is Barrera still so high? I'm more upset about Floyd's opponents than anyone, but besides Wright and Pac, noone else has done anything to move ahead of Floyd. Zab is a more credible opponent than Soliman or Larious. It may not be the fight we all want to see, but I'll take it.{its alot better than the last few}. Then I'll accept Oscar or Margarito. Then hopefully the other one. How about you? Will that change your mind? Let me rephrase the Gatti fight. He was on a hot streak, and any fighter{Margarito,Hatton,Tszyu,Cotto} would take a fight against him. So it's unfair to just judge one guy for that. Even if Floyd beats Zab, he still doesn't go to #1. If Wright beats Taylor, he's 1 for sure. If he loses close, he doesn't drop that far{Taylor just goes up}. If Pac beats Larious then either Barrera or Morrales, he's at least 2, and if Wright loses, he's probably #1.