1) Roy Jones Jr. - Toney by UD, RJJ hasn't aged as well, and I don't think he has the power to get to Toney

2) Bernard Hopkins - Hopkins by UD, let's face it Hopkins is a dirty fighter, who is exactly who it takes to beat someone who is slick.

3) Antonio Tarver - Toney by UD, Tarver is not nearly active enough to do anything to Toney

4) Chris Byrd - Byrd by UD, Toney doesn't have the power to hurt Byrd, I think Byrd is the more tactical puncher, while Toney has the better defense

5) Glen Johnson - Johnson by TKO, Skills and Power Johnson would woop on Toney all night.

6) Evander Holyfield. - Toney by SD, this would be a great match-up either guy could take it.