If Hatton beats Castillo, I will give him credit.
If Castillo beats Hatton, I will give him credit.

Although after last weekends slackerfest, they are both going to
have to step it back-up to impress me.
Killer Sheep

That sums it up nicely. I'd just add that Hatton needs to beat Castillo handily to gain respect. Castillo can win ugly and still walk away with respect cause everyone expects Hatton to latch on to him and never let go.