I'm assuming your talking about your defensive as you use the word "guard". Sorry, different land: different language. It sound like some of your coaches want you to block or catch the punches and some want you to soak them up in your gloves. I think both suggestions work in various situations and providing the style of fighter you are. I would definately suggest you move into a tight defensive is you are a poor mover and if you are fast on the feet....block and counter. Most importanly hold the hands protecting that tucked chin.

OldTownBoxing