Either weight I think Oscar wins. It's not like the first fight was close until oscar got conservative. Yes, it fought that way because he respected Tito's power and yes Tito would still have a punchers chance, but even when Oscar was letting his hands go, Tito still couldn't make him pay for it. I like both fighters, but I actually prefer Tito to Oscar, and at the time, I was pulling for Tito. I wish we could have seen it happen.