Quote Originally Posted by killersheep
Quote Originally Posted by Swashbuckling Gordy
Quote Originally Posted by killersheep
Quote Originally Posted by Swashbuckling Gordy


Joe would win .

Too fast , too busy ,too skillfull and above all far far too strong .
I'm not trying to call you out on anything, but have you ever seen Joe fight someone with a good defense?
Have you ever seen Wright in with anyone of JC superstars strength ,skill ,speed and business ?

Lets face it WW record has been built on nearly men and whilst Joe hasn't always impressed when the time came to stand up and be counted against Lacy he stormed through the breech proving beyond all question his class.

He may have trouble with Brittle hands but is has not hindered his Boxing ability and against Sakio Bika ( one dangerous motherlover ) he lacked some sharpness .

Taylor had Wright in trouble frequently and JC matches Wright in Personal stats unlike Mosely and Quartey who were coming of losses and activity .
That being said it is hard to judge right

I've never seen Winky take on anyone with Joe's abilities.

I've never seen Joe take on anyone with Winky's defense.

both are valid points.

Winky has beat Shane Mosley, Felix Trinidad, Sam Solimon and Ike Quartey

Joe has beat Jeff Lacy



hate when people say joe has only beat lacy; anyone who truly watched the eubank fight would of seen for one a very green calzaghe fighting a very Exp eubank. now i will never say the same eubank turned up as the one in prime who fought benn and watson, but by christ did eubank put on a very very good performance. after the first round knock down eubank gained 5 years and fought a very good fight, calzaghe walked through ALOT of big hits, was in the ring with a very ring smart fighter and it was a hell of a win.

byron mitchel was no chump, was no P4P fighter either, but to batter him in 4 rounds was no easy task, joe did that.

I love winky alot, but joe wins this in a fairly one sided UD or tko - winky has bery little to bring to this fight. his lack of power, and joes superb chin (imo) means winky wont hurt him, i dont think calzaghe has the power he used to, but fired up we have seen how he can work every second for 12 rounds, winky would be in trouble. IMo taylor would of won that fight if he wasnt so lazy and took so many breaks and i rate clazaghe higher than taylor in speed, power, jab, angles, ring smarts, inside work.