Yea I agree with you.. JMM hasn't fought an elite fighter since Manny Pac, which was in mid 2004... I personally try to weigh who I think is actually a better fighter over the what have you done for me lately approach, but even still JMM simply hasn't been active against good fighters and there's no way to speculate whether he is better than those you mentioned.. I mean for him to be above Bernard Hopkins is ludicrous. Really, it is. Hopkins was p4p #1!, almost a year after Marquez drew with Pac, and since then has, (imo) gone 1-1 with Taylor, but either way extremely close fights, then moved up 2 weights to beat the ring's #8 p4p guy.. And now he is suddenly behind someone who drew with Pac a year before he lost to Taylor and hasn't fought a world class fighter since. It's all a bit silly imo. So is having Castillo or Hatton above Hopkins.