Let me guess you feel R. Marquez does not belong that high up because you have not seen enough of him? It is Hatton that does not belong !!! But wait ,you have seen enough of him as we all have by this media generated paper champ. R. Marquez has actually surpassed his brother in talent and production. Barrera has no business being on the list. After seeing Mosley this past week it is just 1-2 fights away from returning to the list.


Quote Originally Posted by bilbo
Quote Originally Posted by BoxingGod
i think the reason why jmm is place at that rank is because us (saddo members) voted him there. the veteran fans have for years appreciated jmm for his masterfull boxing skills, but yes i agree his accomplishment isn't deserving above the bhop or even the young accomplish j.t...but i think his rank has base on his masterfull showing of boxing skills, but then again since his fight with pac, he hasn't been the same masterfull boxer, and he has only gotten older(not better).

but jmm isn't the only one to be question on the list, anyone can pretty much come up with an arguement against or for a fighter. i think the top 3 p4p figher is solid but the order is still argueable. and from 3rd to infinitely its just a total mess.

imo bhop stay top 5 (because he just conquer the lightheavyweight division winning over division king tarver in a fasion true greats do)due to j.t getting two wins over him, jt deserves 4th place.

after 5th it is very hard to know who goes where actually its hard from 1 to infinitely but atleast most of us have pac winky pbf as top three.

as for hatton and joe.C, if anyone list them top ten cotto should be in right with them and so should sugar shane, and mab and jmm somehow stays in the mix of the rankings.

I'm all for replacing Hatton with Mosely. Calzaghe has earned his spot in my opinion, currently the longest reigning world champion at any weight with the most title defenses and still unbeaten.

I don't know enough about R Marquez but I think he's a bit high too, I don't see what he's done that Isreal Vasquez hasn't and I certainly don't have Isreal Vasquez as top 10 pound for pound.