Did Barry Mcguigan deserve to be put in the hall of fame?

[Tysonbruno]

He was good but he only won one world title and only defended it 3 times i say no

[WWatt]

The main reason Barry got in was for reasons outside of boxing - you know, the fact he bonded the Catholics and Protestants when things were on the verge of boiling over in Norn Iron.

It is labelled the INTERNATIONAL Boxing Hall of FAME, afterall.

[WWatt]

Plus he beat the great Pedroza (ofcourse) who was on 20 defences wasn't he?

[Tysonbruno]

Fair points just don't know if he deserved it

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

I suppose its one of those issues were his induction becomes increasingly debatable with the passing of time.

[BIG H]

I suppose its one of those issues were his induction becomes increasingly debatable with the passing of time.

CC for the campest logo on the site

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

I was gonna do it in pink but that would of been too obvious

[BIG H]

I was gonna do it in pink but that would of been too obvious

Mincer

[SEANIE]

He was good but he only won one world title and only defended it 3 times i say no

He beat taylor who was undefeated and lost his title in 120 degrees heat. remember when sugar ray robinson lost for the light heavyweight title he blamed the heat.

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

I was gonna do it in pink but that would of been too obvious

Mincer

Na not at all mate.

:P

[BIG H]

I was gonna do it in pink but that would of been too obvious

Mincer

Na not at all mate.

:P

Hahahahaha

[althetruthhindley]

H e beat an ageing champ ,
I like Barry but for me didnt achive that much when u break it down
so my answer is no.

[BIG H]

H e beat an ageing champ ,
I like Barry but for me didnt achive that much when u break it down
so my answer is no.

Who do you actual like/rate

[CutMeMick]

No IMO Barry does not belong in the HofF.....

I've been saying it but nobody listens to me......

And as I keep saying if hes in there then why question if Gatti deserves the honors?

IMO, once they let Barry in they pretty much open that door wider now.....

[Violent Demise]

Hell fucking no. The boxing Hall of Fame needs to do some cleaning up. The first person who should be tossed out is Mcguigan overrated ass.