Mayweather #1 without a doubt.P4P means that if they were all the same size who would come out on top.Based on facts...
Pac.1.He lunges with his punches 2.he is often off balance 3.he bounces which makes you prone to run into more punches 3.his defense is good but not great.
Mayweather-1.What flaws can you spot?
Winky-1.He stands flat footed at times. 2.He tends to pity pat punches.3.his combinations arent great.
speed-PBF
stamina-PBF
power-PBF-Pac tie
Ring awareness-PBF
expirience-PBF-he was born into the sport(he only has 6 losses in his lifetime)
footwork-PBF
counter punching-PBF-Winky-tie
Excitement-Pac
Defense-PBF-Winky-tie

feel free to make improvements...