winky and flloyd

[oakleyno1]

im sure this has been posted b4 but i cant remember lol!
so, if winky could get down to 154 again, and he and mayweather were to fight
who would win>? and why

[El Gamo]

I'd like to see Floyd at 154 first because it clearly affected Mosley who was just as fast as PBF at lower weights. Right now,I'd say Winky,I don't see how PBF would penetrate that defence unless he countered Winky over his jab and just picked up points. May be make Winky the agressor,let him come forward,use his superbly quick hands and feet and just counter Winky,jab him,pile up the points? Would be a really intriguing fight!

[Bx730NY]

im sure this has been posted b4 but i cant remember lol!
so, if winky could get down to 154 again, and he and mayweather were to fight
who would win>? and why

Winky would win convincingly.

[The Boxer]

i never pick against PBF

[Taeth]

I say Mayweather because Winky is getting hit more, and more, and getting back down to 154 will be hard for him. I always thought Mayweather would give even a prime 154 Winky a hard time because he is so quick of foot, and his timing is so good. If any punch in boxing can get by Winky's guard it's PBF's straight right hand, and though it would never come close to hurting Winky he follows through with it, and makes it hard to counter when it lands.

[The Boxer]

the straight right is the perfect weapon against a southpaw. PBF throws his straight righthand better than some fighters throw a left jab.

[MannyP]

im sure this has been posted b4 but i cant remember lol!
so, if winky could get down to 154 again, and he and mayweather were to fight
who would win>? and why

I would tend to agree with those picking Winky, but even with Winky's physical advantages (in terms of size), his lack of any meaningful power could make this fight interesting.

Winky is a pretty sound fighter so I would expect him to use his jab and size to neutralize Floyd's speed, and out point him over 12 rounds. However, Floyd does have the skill to manage the distance between them, get inside, and really give Winky problems. In this match up, this is where Winky's lack of any real power could become a major problem. I personally believe that Floyd could manage Winky's reach and defense better than Mosley did, but until I see more of Floyd against bigger fighters I have difficulty believing he could pull it off.

[petem]

WINKY far too big

plain and simple

MAYWEATHER says he can still make 140

[DaxxKahn]

I say Mayweather because Winky is getting hit more, and more, and getting back down to 154 will be hard for him. I always thought Mayweather would give even a prime 154 Winky a hard time because he is so quick of foot, and his timing is so good. If any punch in boxing can get by Winky's guard it's PBF's straight right hand, and though it would never come close to hurting Winky he follows through with it, and makes it hard to counter when it lands.

I have to agree..IMO Age is catching up with him...If this was the Winky from 2 years ago I go with Wright all day for the simple fact of size and the obvious how the hell could Folyd score anything real on him?...Winky's defense was that good

[Jimanuel Boogustus]

WINKY far too big

plain and simple

MAYWEATHER says he can still make 140

Agreed, Mayweather weight 146 in his last fight two fights (actually ate his way up to 146 against Baldomir) and i doubt very much that he will weigh more than 150 against Oscar.

I don't think his speed will be affected though. No he'll be just as fast as a light middle.

[Taeth]

I say Mayweather because Winky is getting hit more, and more, and getting back down to 154 will be hard for him. I always thought Mayweather would give even a prime 154 Winky a hard time because he is so quick of foot, and his timing is so good. If any punch in boxing can get by Winky's guard it's PBF's straight right hand, and though it would never come close to hurting Winky he follows through with it, and makes it hard to counter when it lands.

I have to agree..IMO Age is catching up with him...If this was the Winky from 2 years ago I go with Wright all day for the simple fact of size and the obvious how the hell could Folyd score anything real on him?...Winky's defense was that good

Well the Mosley who got outboxed by ODLH the second time, and had already lost to Forrest was able to hit Winky, and that was Mosley at his worst. PBF is a much smarter and faster boxer than Mosley was at that point. I see PBF getting by Winky's defense, and PBF is also very good against the jab, and countering off of it. Judah tried throwing the jab alot, and that was when Mayweather was able to counter most effectively was off the jab. And as good as Winky's defense is, Mayweather defense is better, especially on the outside.

[the phenom]

i say i cant pick but i would have to evaluate like this
winky is way bigger naturally ...size plays an advantage
hes defense is great but can he catch floyd with meaning ful puches?
floyd is fast and can counter quick enough to catch him i say floyby rather a dominant 12 round decesion
because winky is ow exactly a power puncher just very thechnichally sound

[Brockton Bomber]

This would add up to a man-sized azz whipping for PBF. Winky has more than enough power to hurt a natural 140 pound fighter. PBF would be fwocked. I don't eben think he'd be decisioned. He'd get TKO'd.

[Olympian904]

i never pick against PBF