Quote Originally Posted by El Gamo
Nope,I totally think John was manipulated.Jack wanted to leave the island??!?!?!!? John blew up the sub so o one can leave? Repercussions on jack and John's relationship>?!?!?! "a box with anything you want inside?"?!?!?! Is' John's dad really here? Is it an imagination? What relationship does John have with the island(even Ben said John had a relationsip with the island!)!


Quote Originally Posted by Preme
i wouldn't say john got manipulated as such, just ben didn't stop him blowing the sub up...

"this box" thing sounds a bit F****** nuts tho; i hope its a metephore of sorts, 'co\ come on you can't just have a F****** box that has in it what ever u wished for, i mean the world would be full of jessica albas for fucks sake!

His father must of been doing a runner and some how got stranded there and the others found him? Oh, and anyone else thinking Johns father is the conn man who fucked Sawyers family over? The 'real Sawyer' if you will? So far everyone seems to have a link yeah Sawyer met jacks/claires dad in the land down under, but john don;t see to be linked ot anyone yet, i think its his dad who is the conn man who done what ever it was to Sawyers mother that made his dad kill um both, the one Sawyer has been carrying or was carrying that ntoe around for!
I mentioned this while ago too,great minds! I'm 10000000% John's dad is the REAL Sawyer.
they sure do

Yeah im certain his dad is there! As i am certain jack's and claires dad is to, or he WAS there, witht he sub gone now is he still there? i don't know, but i think when jack 'seen' him it was him. I don;t think John was manpiulated to blow the sub up 'coz he just went into bens room to find out where the subw as with the full intention of blowing it up.. ben may not of stopped him, but it wasn't IMO bens influence that made John blow it up, if he knew where it was he would of just gone right ahead and one it without seeking ben out.

This box thing is gunna get people talking. When you think about it, they needed to add something new tho, otherwise all there would be left is to explain the others, now 'The box' will take us to more of the Island, and if John does have a connection to it. I am uncertain as to weather Johns back was actually broken, was it something to do with his mind? his dad trying to kill him, his back hurt, did he refuse to do the work to walk again? could he have walked if he wanted to? Remeber there was somethign when they went in search for the second hatch, the monitoring room, or the plane? i forget what one but he when it apprered as though he was wrong his legs started to go on him then - it could be a phsycological effect. That leaves us with rose tho, the chick who was dying, that there was no cure and i think they made out should of been dead by now (although we havn't seen her or hubby for sometime)

I got a felling that next week we will be back to the beach, and i think that the couple who are 'new' to us in season three will start becoming major players in this story. Maybe a flash back about them next week and what thier crack was back in the day!