I don't think Soliman is a good indication of how Oscar would do against Winky. First of all Soliman is far more the volume puncher than Oscar is, and that's the only way to be affective against Winky, and still he won almost every round in that fight. Another point is that Winky has beaten, and maybe will be every guy who has beaten Oscar should he beat Hopkins. He beat Mosley, and Quartey quite easily, and also dismantled Trinidad. I feel he won the fight against Vargas by a large margin, and also that he beat Taylor by 3-4 rounds. The bigger question is can Oscar beat Floyd, and even if he doesn't he may still fight Winky. At this point I can't see Winky getting back down to 154 so its a fight that won't happen, but if it does Winky would beat Oscar. He has a better jab, he throws more punches, and he gets hit alot less.