How Would Gerald McClellan do today?

[Majesty]

I didn't say Jermain was a better boxer I said he had better "technique"

[JT Rock]

I dont know bro.. I have seen them both especially Jermain obviously since he is active, and his technique is nothing to write home about, his athleticism has kept him in the fights with Hopkins and Winky, I thought he looked really bad against Ouma and I know Spinks will give him all sorts of problems.. I am starting to get confident enough to do a signature bet with you over Taylor vs Spinks

[Beanflicker]

I'm with you man, I think the G-Man would thrive today. I think Mcclellan could have gone down as one of the greats, I think he had a lot more time to grow and expand moreso as a fighter if not for the injury. Can you imagine how boxing history might have been altered if he won the Benn fight and fought Roy Jones? A guy like Mcclellan would be a huge threat to Jones IMO and it would be great to see them rematched in the pros. It's a damn shame what happened to the G-Man, he was probably one of the most vicious punchers I've ever seen. A real waste

[X]

I'm with you man, I think the G-Man would thrive today. I think Mcclellan could have gone down as one of the greats, I think he had a lot more time to grow and expand moreso as a fighter if not for the injury. Can you imagine how boxing history might have been altered if he won the Benn fight and fought Roy Jones? A guy like Mcclellan would be a huge threat to Jones IMO and it would be great to see them rematched in the pros. It's a damn shame what happened to the G-Man, he was probably one of the most vicious punchers I've ever seen. A real waste

And I think Jones was quite wise to never get in the ring with Nigel Benn !!!!

[Majesty]

I'm with you man, I think the G-Man would thrive today. I think Mcclellan could have gone down as one of the greats, I think he had a lot more time to grow and expand moreso as a fighter if not for the injury. Can you imagine how boxing history might have been altered if he won the Benn fight and fought Roy Jones? A guy like Mcclellan would be a huge threat to Jones IMO and it would be great to see them rematched in the pros. It's a damn shame what happened to the G-Man, he was probably one of the most vicious punchers I've ever seen. A real waste

And I think Jones was quite wise to never get in the ring with Nigel Benn !!!!

Nigel Benn was quite wise to not get in the ring with James Toney who Roy had the gull to fight in his FIRST fight at Super Middleweight

[Beanflicker]

Benn was a tough customer for anyone, but I think Jones would have outclassed him with his foot movement and his quick combos. I'm a huge fan of Nigel's and I respect him for having the heart of a lion and being one of the most exciting fighters around, but I think he would have been outclassed by Jones or Toney.

[El Kabong]

McClellan would do very well today at 160 and even 168.

I think McClellan-Calzaghe is interesting to ponder as is McClellan-Hopkins, McClellan-RJJ, McClellan-any young guys at 160.

I think he would just THUMP Miranda, he'd destroy Green, he'd whup Abraham.....he'd beat Jermain Taylor IF JT is as high strung as usual for such big fights.

[Majesty]

I dont know bro.. I have seen them both especially Jermain obviously since he is active, and his technique is nothing to write home about, his athleticism has kept him in the fights with Hopkins and Winky, I thought he looked really bad against Ouma and I know Spinks will give him all sorts of problems.. I am starting to get confident enough to do a signature bet with you over Taylor vs Spinks

Spinks won't give him the problems of Ouma. Ouma's entire styel and gameplan is getting inside and throwing lots of punches. Taylor likes to fight at distance. Thats why Ouma could do that.

On the other hand Spinks likes to fight at a distance, Taylor likes to fight at a distance...


What do you think's going to happen?

[El Kabong]

....also Spinks doesn't have that great of a chin. I think JT might just crack him and put him out.

HOWEVER the jab of JT is the bread and butter of his offense if he uses it successfully he'll win easy. Spinks is crafty though

[zhubin]

Gerald was a physical beast. Remember, Benn was one tough SOB...and Gerald knocked him out of the ring early on...and i still believe that if the ref wasn't such a moron, the tragic outcome of that fight would never have happened. He would have given anyone problems. I only wish him and Roy got a chance to face each other...that would have been worth the hype.

[DaxxKahn]

Everyone knows I'm a huge G-man fan, despite whatever speculation about his out of ring life, I think the world of his ability and power freakish aggressiveness.. Tragedy aside, I feel that the G-man would dominate this era quite easily.... His Boxing ability and speed were vastly underrated and overshadowed by his bludgeoning power..

MIDDLEWEIGHT

Jermain Taylor- with Taylors propensity to back into corners and the ropes would spell his demise, Gerald knocks him in to tomorrow

Winky Wright- to small and not enough fire power to keep McClellan off of him.. those helacious punches would find there way through the guard

Bernard Hopkins- This one would be interesting due to Hopkins defense and toughness, Hopkins had good power himself, this one would probably be the closest.

Edison Miranda- this one would mirror his fights with Julian Jackson

Arthur Abraham- just plain gets murdered

Felix Strum, Kelly Pavlik, Javier Castillejo all wouldn't make it out of the 3rd round


What are your guys thoughts?

I totaly afree with everything you said...Though Hopkins might be slick enough to win a decision...Though it depends on the night...Yes G-Man would send all these guys in both the Middle and Super middleweight divisions home with their tail between their leg's and thoughts of a new profession

[tedsares]

Everyone knows I'm a huge G-man fan, despite whatever speculation about his out of ring life, I think the world of his ability and power freakish aggressiveness.. Tragedy aside, I feel that the G-man would dominate this era quite easily.... His Boxing ability and speed were vastly underrated and overshadowed by his bludgeoning power..

MIDDLEWEIGHT

Jermain Taylor- with Taylors propensity to back into corners and the ropes would spell his demise, Gerald knocks him in to tomorrow

Winky Wright- to small and not enough fire power to keep McClellan off of him.. those helacious punches would find there way through the guard

Bernard Hopkins- This one would be interesting due to Hopkins defense and toughness, Hopkins had good power himself, this one would probably be the closest.

Edison Miranda- this one would mirror his fights with Julian Jackson

Arthur Abraham- just plain gets murdered

Felix Strum, Kelly Pavlik, Javier Castillejo all wouldn't make it out of the 3rd round


What are your guys thoughts?

Pretty much agree. He was special.

[althetruthhindley]

i think Gerald SMOKES all of the middles in question and he SMOKES all of the super middles of today as well , he was a special fighter with awsome power i really miss him and his style .

[Swashbuckling Gordy]

# 1502 and 1324 respectively to the 2 of you Roberto and Gamo

I was thinking SUPERMIDDLEWEIGHT

Joe Calzaghe- Joe has the workrate and elusiveness and ability to show angles, I still think Gerald can take him by round 6

Mikkel Kessler- I feel the same what the outcome as I do with the Calzaghe fight

Anthony Mundine- Gone by round 3

Carl Froch- Unless he learns to keep his hands up he aint gonna last 2 long I'll say 1st round KO

Jeff Lacy - Same as Miranda

Allan Green- Gets chased all over the arena through the crowd WWE style until G-man KO's him in the Locker room

Not trying to be a fanboy but if someone see any of these guys winning please elaborate, I just cant see it happening

Has anyone ever told you your really boring ?

Honestly smokers are jokers !!!

McClelland overated got found out sad end case closed stop going on about 2 fights against someone who was blind in 1 eye !!!

( Julian Jackson )

[No Contest]

[youtube=425,350]4ZjweFP9H7o[/youtube]
Heres a cool highlight video of McClellan, dropping bombs. I dont know how Julian Jackson got up....he got tko'd few seconds later but he got up.....